
Strategy schools: the 4 approaches of Whittington
How does a successful strategy come about? Through rigorous, rational planning in advance, or through an organic process of trial, error and moving with the market? Because no single method is the answer, Richard Whittington developed a matrix of four quadrants in which the classical and modern strategy schools come together. Each quadrant shows its own archetype of strategy formation.
Key takeaways
- Whittington orders strategy schools along two questions: which goal does the strategy serve (profit maximisation or broader interests) and how does it come about (deliberately planned or emergent)?
- Classical: profit through rational planning; formulation and execution are strictly separated.
- Evolutionary: profit, but planning is pointless; the market selects and management keeps looking for fit.
- Processual: strategy emerges through learning and adapting within a coalition of groups with their own goals.
- Systemic: strategy can be planned, but goals and means are embedded in social networks and local culture.
What are strategy schools?
Strategy schools are coherent approaches to how strategy comes about and what it is for. Whittington groups them into four: the classical, evolutionary, processual and systemic approach.
Strategy matters: it is the compass with which organisations navigate an ever more complex world. Richard Whittington, Professor of Strategic Management at Saïd Business School, University of Oxford, fills the quadrants of his matrix by asking two simple but fundamental questions. On the vertical axis: which goal? The extremes are the monistic perspective (profit maximisation) and the pluralistic perspective, which combines social and economic goals. On the horizontal axis: how? The extremes are deliberate and emergent.
The four strategy schools in one matrix
Goal on one axis, process on the other.

Goal
Process
Classical
Profit maximisation
Deliberate, planned
Evolutionary
Profit maximisation
Emergent
Processual
Pluralistic
Emergent
Systemic
Pluralistic
Deliberate, planned
1. The classical approach
The starting point is to gain more advantage than the competition; the ultimate goal of a company is to be profitable. The way to achieve this is rational planning, so strategy formation is the same as strategic planning. What is needed to achieve the strategic goals can be derived logically from the goals, which are formulated explicitly and fixed before planning begins. Planning is a controlled thought process: rational, detached and sequential. Ansoff was the founder of this way of making strategy; Sloan, Chandler and Porter can also be regarded as classical strategists. They aim to secure the future of the organisation through above-average profitability.
- Outside-in. The outside world is seen as the most decisive factor. People are regarded as homo economicus.
- At a distance. A strategy can best be developed through rational analysis in a place where the noise of daily practice does not penetrate.
- Formulation separated from execution. Formulating is exclusively the task of top management; execution is delegated to lower levels, on the assumption that it will then proceed without many problems.
2. The evolutionary approach
The evolutionary approach also starts from the economic mono-perspective, but here the strategy arises spontaneously: you cannot plan a strategy ahead. The basis was laid by Hannan and Freeman (1989), who turned to biology: why do certain animals survive changes in their environment and others not? The environment of the organisation is both harsh and unpredictable, and competition is aggressive and dynamic. Planning is pointless.
Only one possibility remains for management: continuously responding to the environment and the competition. The market is ‘perfect’ and determines whether the strategic answer is successful. Strategy is the manager’s search for a fit between the organisation and the continuously changing environment. After each step you examine which next step offers the most opportunities: differentiating and experimenting. Only when you look back do you recognise a pattern in the actions.
3. The processual approach
The processual approach also assumes emergent strategy formation and a market that selects. The difference is that this selection is not merciless but ‘mild’ (Vrakking, 2001): the market is not perfect, so an economically maximal result is not attainable. An optimal result is possible if you respond to market imperfections and the implementation succeeds, which requires much attention to implementation and an organisation flexible enough to adapt.
Cyert and March (1963), who laid the basis for this approach, see people as inclined to take the easy way and as biased, and therefore only rational to a limited extent. Political games are played. The company is seen as a coalition of groups of participants, each pursuing its own objectives; such a coalition cannot be expected to pursue profit maximisation as its only goal, nor to rally behind one logical long-term plan. Management must therefore see strategy formation as a process of learning and adapting from a strategic vision. The approach increases the chance of conservative strategies, because not all participants recognise the need for change to the same degree.
4. The systemic approach
This approach is also called the institutional approach. The basis was laid by Mark Granovetter (1985) in an article setting out the concept of embeddedness: economic relations between individuals or companies are always embedded in actual social networks. Granovetter thereby puts the exclusively economic approach into perspective. Organisations all have to deal with specific markets, political relations and cultural systems, and the strategy is shaped by the character of all these factors.
Within the social system of the organisation the goal is determined, the strategy is developed and matters other than profit are given priority. Goals and means are always connected with the local culture. People are able to make rational plans, unlike what the processual approach assumes, but the social environment determines which higher interests a strategy must serve. This also explains the large differences between countries: the strategy of comparable companies looks different in Japan than in the United States or the Netherlands.
Conclusion: choose the approach that fits your circumstances
With his matrix Whittington gives insight into four approaches to strategy formation and shows what a strategy is and why it matters. Managers can choose which approach best fits their specific circumstances and the dynamics of their organisation.
How Diamond Decisions uses the strategy schools
Diamond Decisions combines planning with learning. Inspiration sessions make the environment and its dynamics visible, business modeling records the deliberate choices, data analytics shows what actually emerges in practice, and the decision makers adjust the strategy on the basis of what they learn.
Talk to the author
Leo KerklaanDiamond Decisions
Discuss your question with Leo
From ambition to action. In a no-obligation conversation we explore together which KPIs and indicators really matter.
Schedule an introduction →Step 2 of our approach
Business Modeling
Together we translate your strategy into a business model with clear KPIs and goals.
Explore Business Modeling →Frequently asked questions
01
Which strategy schools does Whittington distinguish?
Four: the classical, the evolutionary, the processual and the systemic approach.
02
What are the two axes of Whittington’s matrix?
The goal of the strategy, from profit maximisation to pluralistic goals, and the process by which it comes about, from deliberate to emergent.
03
What is the difference between the classical and the evolutionary approach?
Both aim at profit. The classical approach believes in rational planning in advance; the evolutionary approach considers planning pointless and lets the market select what works.
04
What is the difference between the processual and the systemic approach?
Both recognise more goals than profit. The processual approach sees strategy as learning and adapting by people with limited rationality; the systemic approach holds that rational planning is possible, but that the social and cultural context determines goals and means.
05
Which strategy school fits an SME?
Often a mix: a short, deliberate plan with a few clear choices, combined with fast learning from customers and figures. In a family business the systemic view also applies: continuity and values weigh alongside profit.
Further reading
Sources
- Whittington, R. (2001). What is Strategy – and does it matter?
- Hannan, M.T. and Freeman, J. (1989). Organizational Ecology.
- Cyert, R.M. and March, J.G. (1963). A Behavioral Theory of the Firm.
- Granovetter, M. (1985). Economic action and social structure: the problem of embeddedness. American Journal of Sociology.
About the author
About Diamond Decisions
Diamond Decisions helps organizations become better by enabling better decisions. We don’t start with data, dashboards or AI, but with the decision that needs to improve, and work back from there to KPIs, data and technology. We do that in four steps: inspiration and alignment, business modeling, analytics and data platform and data-driven decision makers. That way BI and AI don’t remain an IT project, but deliver value every day.

