Key takeaways
- One version of the truth means that everyone works with the same definitions and the same source, so that the origin and reliability of data are clear.
- Information systems that do not draw on one common source lead to inefficient communication and sometimes to completely wrong decisions.
- Collecting data and information can take up to 80% of decision-making time; little remains for analysis and weighing.
- With BI and one unambiguous source the ratio can shift to 20% collecting, 50% analyzing and deciding, and 30% for other matters such as innovation.
- Unambiguous definitions are a foundation, not a guarantee: research shows the difference in BI success is smaller than often assumed.
What is one version of the truth?
One version of the truth means that everyone in the organization uses the same definitions and the same data source for the indicators on which the organization is steered.
It ends debates about the definitions of performance indicators and makes clear where data comes from and how reliable it is. In many boardrooms differences of opinion still exist about the meaning of information, because every manager has his own information system or his own interpretation.
Completely wrong decisions
Sometimes management does not even notice that different definitions are in use. Organizations often have several “information systems” on the basis of which managers and knowledge workers take decisions. When these do not draw on one common source or do not use the same definitions, this often leads to inefficient communication about reality. It can even lead to completely wrong decisions.
How important is it for BI success?
Working with unambiguous definitions is more or less regarded as the holy grail of BI and should in principle contribute a lot to success. However, the difference between organizations that achieve good results with business intelligence and those that do not turns out not to be very large on this point, according to the Dutch National BI Survey and the research report on the seven biggest pitfalls in business intelligence. One version of the truth is a necessary foundation, but not sufficient on its own.
Realize one version of the truth with BI
With business intelligence, definitions can be aligned across departments, business units and hierarchical levels. The service level for the inventory department is calculated in the same way as the service level the account manager uses. But the information must also be consistent when the underlying data is stored in different systems.
During the implementation of a BI system it often turns out that data is not consistent. Customer numbers in the order system, for example, do not match the customer numbers in the financial administration. BI therefore provides cleansed data that can be combined and integrated, so that the information derived from it becomes consistent. Across the different systems and big data flows a reliable and integral picture of the business processes and the customers can then arise.
The decision-making process has two phases
Decision-making can be divided into two phases: collecting data and information, and then analyzing the data and taking the decision. Managers often think they are taking a decision while they are in fact collecting data and information, or having it collected. The first phase can take up as much as eighty percent of the time. The remainder is left for analyzing and actually weighing the pros and cons. This does not benefit decisions that are often taken under time pressure.
The darkness of intuition
Other research shows that analyzing and diagnosing data, a decisive phase in decision-making, often remains unnamed. Hopefully it takes place “in the darkness of judgement and intuition” (Mintzberg, 2004). With BI and a common, unambiguous source of business data the proportions can be completely different. The manager then needs only 20% of the time for gathering information and can spend 50% on analyzing and deciding. Facts combine more easily with intuition. It is quite conceivable that managers can spend the remaining 30% on other things, such as innovation.
Decision-making time without and with one version of the truth
How a manager’s time shifts when there is one unambiguous source.
Without one version
With one version
Collecting information
Up to 80% of the time
About 20% of the time
Analyzing and deciding
The remaining 20%
About 50% of the time
Other matters
No room
About 30%, e.g. innovating
Boardroom debate
About whose figures are right
About what to do
Definitions
Per manager or system
Shared across the organization
How Diamond Decisions creates one version of the truth
Diamond Decisions starts with the definitions, not the tooling. In business modeling we record what each indicator means and where it comes from, in data analytics we build one integrated source, and decision makers then discuss actions instead of figures.
Conclusion
At a time when managers must decide ever more often and ever faster about diverse matters, one version of the truth is no luxury. It does not guarantee success with BI, but without it a large part of the time goes to gathering and disputing figures instead of analyzing and deciding.
Talk to the author
Dick PouwDiamond Decisions
Discuss your question with Dick
Tell us which decision needs to improve. In a no-obligation conversation we show you where your data delivers the most.
Schedule an introduction →Step 3 of our approach
Diamond Data Analytics
A data warehouse that starts with your most important decisions and is ready for conversational AI: a working prototype within 24 hours.
Explore Data Analytics →Frequently asked questions
01
What does one version of the truth mean?
That everyone in the organization uses the same definitions and the same data source for the indicators used for steering, so that figures no longer differ per manager, department or system.
02
What is the difference between one version of the truth and a data warehouse?
One version of the truth is the goal: shared definitions and consistent figures. A data warehouse is a means: a central store in which data from several systems is cleansed and integrated. Without agreed definitions a data warehouse does not deliver one truth.
03
Why do figures differ between departments?
Because departments use their own systems, calculation methods and interpretations, and because master data such as customer numbers does not match between systems. Each figure is then correct within its own definition, but they cannot be compared.
04
How does an SME achieve one version of the truth?
Choose the five to ten indicators on which you steer, write down one definition and one source per indicator, appoint an owner and have all reports draw on that source. That requires agreements first and technology second.
Further reading
Sources
- Henry Mintzberg, Managers Not MBAs (2004)
About the author
About Diamond Decisions
Diamond Decisions helps organizations become better by enabling better decisions. We don’t start with data, dashboards or AI, but with the decision that needs to improve, and work back from there to KPIs, data and technology. We do that in four steps: inspiration and alignment, business modeling, analytics and data platform and data-driven decision makers. That way BI and AI don’t remain an IT project, but deliver value every day.


