Key takeaways
- Revenue, revenue growth and margin are results; they should never dominate your steering.
- Steering on costs usually goes hand in hand with lower quality. Steer on quality and costs go down by themselves.
- There are only a few real KPIs. A municipality with more than a thousand KPIs will not score.
- A KPI without data is an empty shell: look at smaller disasters or near misses for which you do have data.
- Without a feedback loop the story behind the figures does not come alive and wrong decisions follow.
Defining and measuring KPIs is no easy trick
Many companies and (government) institutions love key performance indicators and SMART goals. That is logical, because they are powerful tools for managers, improvement teams and controllers. KPIs sit at the heart of every organization. The art is to find them (there are only a few) and to define them correctly, so that you can adjust faster and improve your processes daily. But determining KPIs and steering on them is not always easy. A mistake is quickly made. Before you know it you have far too many of them, or the discussion about the definition flares up again.
The five pitfalls at a glance
What goes wrong and what works better.
What goes wrong
What works better
1. Revenue
Growth hides losses
Add process indicators
2. Costs
Steering in the rear-view mirror
Steer on quality and predictive KPIs
3. Laundry list
More than a thousand KPIs
A handful of real KPIs
4. No data
An empty shell
Measure near misses
5. No feedback
Action without the story
Discuss scores regularly
Pitfall 1: staring blindly at revenue and revenue growth
A well-known paint manufacturer steered purely on the indicators revenue and market share. The remuneration of senior management was linked to them. A thorough analysis of process indicators showed that the more market share was won, the higher the loss per litre of paint produced. The board did not want to discuss this information and continued on the chosen path. The consequence: two years later the company was in very heavy weather.
It is very common for entrepreneurs and managers to steer on revenue, revenue growth and margin, but these should never be allowed to dominate.
Pitfall 2: being mesmerized by costs
A mental healthcare institution invested a lot of money in a management information system. The first “KPI” that was built and put into use was personnel costs. When the annual accounts were drawn up there turned out to be a loss of almost five million euros. The cause: too many beds were empty too often (a process-oriented KPI), partly because the waiting lists had dried up (a market-oriented KPI).
Of course an entrepreneur or manager also has to watch costs. What goes wrong here is that there are other KPIs earlier in the process that have predictive value for future costs and margin. Moreover, steering on costs usually goes hand in hand with lower quality. It is better to steer on quality; then your costs go down by themselves.
Pitfall 3: making a laundry list of KPIs
A medium-sized municipality named more than a thousand KPIs: several dozen for each service, department and team. The project was called “DOELPUNT” (goal). But with so many KPIs it is very hard to score. Compare it with a football team. A good coach does not field eleven strikers. Not only is that far too expensive, the chance of success is also very small, because the lesser strikers get in the way of the top scorers. In organizations too you can lose the overview, with an overcrowded dashboard as a result and no KPI effect.
Pitfall 4: KPIs without data
One question always helps to find real KPIs: what is the biggest disaster that can happen to your organization? Daan van Beek tells: “When I gave a masterclass in Singapore, I asked that disaster question too. It puts participants on the right track at once. One of them worked for a company with ships all over the world transporting gas and oil. His answer caused some hilarity: when a ship sinks.”
Statistically that happens once every hundred years. So you have a real, genuine KPI, but no data to calculate it. It turns out to be an empty shell. The art is then to look at smaller disasters or near misses for which you do have data.
Pitfall 5: KPIs without a feedback loop
How sad is it when someone has the right insights but still does not decide, or even takes the wrong decisions? A retailer had named exactly the right KPIs and also had the data ready. Every week they were on the management dashboard, ready to be seen and used. But the director failed to discuss the scores regularly with the product managers, especially when the scores were not good. He went straight into action and dropped exactly the wrong products. The story behind the figures did not come alive, because feedback from his employees was missing. And as the saying goes: “feedback is the breakfast of champions”.
How Diamond Decisions avoids these pitfalls
All five blunders have the same root: the KPI is not connected to a decision. In business modeling we start from the decisions that drive the result and derive a small number of KPIs from them, check in data analytics whether the data exists, and build the feedback loop with the decision makers who have to act on the scores.
Prevention is much better than cure
Look beyond revenue and costs, choose a handful of KPIs for which you have data and discuss the scores with the people who know the story behind the figures. Then KPIs do what they are meant to do: help you adjust faster and improve every day.
Talk to the author
Daan van BeekDiamond Decisions
Discuss your question with Daan
From ambition to action. In a no-obligation conversation we explore together which KPIs and indicators really matter.
Schedule an introduction →Step 2 of our approach
Business Modeling
Together we translate your strategy into a business model with clear KPIs and goals.
Explore Business Modeling →Frequently asked questions
01
What are the biggest mistakes with KPIs?
The five biggest are: steering only on revenue and growth, being obsessed with costs, defining far too many KPIs, choosing KPIs for which there is no data and not discussing the scores with the people involved.
02
How many KPIs should an organization have?
Only a few. Real KPIs are scarce: they measure the processes that are critical for success. A team can usually manage with three to five; an organization with more than a thousand has indicators, not KPIs.
03
What is the difference between steering on costs and steering on quality?
Costs are a result that you see afterwards; quality is created in the process and predicts future costs and margin. Steering on costs often lowers quality, while steering on quality reduces errors, rework and ultimately costs.
04
How does a small company avoid these KPI pitfalls?
Ask the disaster question, choose a few process KPIs for which you already have data and put them on the agenda of a weekly meeting. In a small company the feedback loop is short, which is an advantage.
Further reading
About the author
About Diamond Decisions
Diamond Decisions helps organizations become better by enabling better decisions. We don’t start with data, dashboards or AI, but with the decision that needs to improve, and work back from there to KPIs, data and technology. We do that in four steps: inspiration and alignment, business modeling, analytics and data platform and data-driven decision makers. That way BI and AI don’t remain an IT project, but deliver value every day.


